The Fat Apple offers a delightful blend of New York-style pizza and Italian classics. The menu showcases a variety of pizzas, including the renowned NY white pizza and a selection of thin crust options that are perfect for pizza enthusiasts. Customers rave about the garlic knots, which make for a great starter. There are also flavorful hoagies and antipasto salad available, ensuring something tasty for everyone. For those looking for more variety, the restaurant serves wings to complement the hearty choices. Prices are budget-friendly, averaging around $9.33, making it an ideal spot for families and casual pizza nights. The simplicity of the menu lets the quality of the food shine through.