The Fat Apple

Discover The Fat Apple Pizza in North Fort Myers, FL, offering delicious NY-style pizza, garlic knots, wings, hoagies, and more in a cozy, family-owned setting. Call +1 239-567-4743 today!

Welcome to The Fat Apple

Signature Dining Experience

The Fat Apple
The Fat Apple
The Fat Apple
The Fat Apple

At The Fat Apple, pizza lovers find their paradise on Bayshore Road in North Fort Myers. This family-owned gem specializes in authentic New York-style pizza that transports diners straight to the busy streets of the Big Apple. Whether you crave the classic thin crust or the creamy indulgence of a white pizza, the menu offers flavors to satisfy every palate. Garlic knots pull diners in with their irresistible aroma, making them a must-try. With a quiet atmosphere, it’s perfect for families, friends, or anyone looking for a relaxed dining experience. Enjoy a slice while savoring the company of loved ones, and experience what makes The Fat Apple a community favorite.

Location & Contact

Address

6704 Bayshore Rd #101, North Fort Myers, FL 33917, United States

Phone

+1 239-567-4743

About

The Fat Apple
The Fat Apple
The Fat Apple
The Fat Apple

The Fat Apple is more than just a pizzeria; it’s a gathering place for the North Fort Myers community. This restaurant prides itself on serving authentic New York-style pizza, which is a hit among locals and visitors alike. The dough is handmade daily, ensuring freshness that enhances the taste of each pie. The pizza features a thin crust that's crisp on the outside but soft and chewy inside, forming the perfect base for an array of toppings. Popular choices include classic pepperoni, fresh vegetables, and the decadent white pizza topped with ricotta and mozzarella.

In addition to pizza, The Fat Apple offers a selection of starters perfect for sharing.

Mozzarella sticks and Bowlin Alley fries are popular companions, while the antipasto salad serves as a flavorful side. On busy days, such as Fridays, when capacity hits 100% at 5 PM, customers can relax knowing they can enjoy great food in a laid-back atmosphere. This humble eatery also caters to families, with spacious seating that accommodates larger parties.

Customer service at The Fat Apple reflects the family-oriented values the establishment upholds. Every guest is treated like a friend, fostering a warm environment that encourages relaxation and enjoyment of the food.

Many patrons come back regularly not just for the food but for the friendly faces and cozy ambiance. The vibe complements any occasion, whether it's a casual dinner with family or a celebration among friends. The Fat Apple continues to grow its presence in the local dining scene and remains committed to quality ingredients and recipes passed down through generations.

Work Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-9 PM
  • Friday11 AM-10 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9 PM

The Fat Apple stands out with its bold, flavorful dishes and welcoming environment. New York-style pizza is the star, with a menu crafted to ensure every bite delivers an authentic experience. The pizza shines with options like garlic knots, hoagies, and crispy wings, all at approachable prices. An antipasto salad accompanies pizzas perfectly, offering a fresh, crunchy contrast. The Fat Apple also caters to lunch and dinner customers alike, with busy times identified and recommendations for peak hours offered, ensuring guests enjoy their meals without excessive waiting. Families flock here, making it a community staple for gatherings, celebrating all things pizza together, and enjoying delicious moments.

The Fat Apple

The Fat Apple’s exterior exudes a welcoming charm with its colorful signage and cozy outdoor seating area. Nestled in a convenient location along Bayshore Road, it invites visitors to step inside and indulge in mouthwatering flavors. The outdoor vibe provides a relaxed setting perfect for enjoying a meal while soaking up the nearby community atmosphere. Families can gather outside for casual conversations over a delicious pizza, making it a great spot to unwind in the Florida sunshine.

Customer Reviews

Called in an order, very friendly and polite and insightful on the ingredients. Was told it was be done in about 15 minutes (I was already walking in to pay as I called the order in because I live close by and was out), the lady who helped me was quick and very friendly. The inside was clean and rustic vibes but a calmness to it. The pizza and garlic knots were done in about 6-7 minutes, and I ended up paying about 25-30$ total which is less than any chain, and it's a nice thin crust pizza. The garlic knots were the best in north fort Myers, so "The Fat Apple" will receive my business in the future. And they should receive yours as well if you were looking for good food at a good price from a local place.

L
Logan G.

Ordered the antipasta with lettuce on the side because of my dietary issues and when I got my order it was so beautifully packages and everything individually containers. They went above and beyond. Thank you

K
Kara L.

Not only is this the best NY style pizza I've had outside of NY, this certainly beats most in NY also. Crust is thin and perfectly crispy

R
Ryan L.

Food is very delicious . Handicap friendly and if you want Takeout they have a Drive thru for Pickup. We got the Ny White pizza and Garlic knots and it was Very Hot and Delicious. The Sweets Treats were scrumptious. Highly recommend next time you want Pizza . Thank you for The Great experience.

S
Sherry L.

Excellent pizza ! Still our ultimate favorite place for pizza Tried the Cecilian pizza and let me just tell you Update ::: after 4 plus years this is still my go to for pizza

j
julieee m.

Best pizza in the area. Family owned and you can feel that when you walk in.

K
Kevin K.